Lifestyle

What My Family Makes and Buys for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving family meal with homemade dishes and store-bought holiday dinner options

What My Family Makes and Buys for Thanksgiving?

  • Date published:  November 20, 2026

Table of Contents

Introduction

A week before Thanksgiving, I called my sister to ask what she was serving. This will be her first Thanksgiving in the home she recently bought, and she’s hosting our family and her in-laws. I wanted to bring something she could actually use, so I figured I’d ask before volunteering a dish. Her answer was, “Anything and bring an empty stomach because you’re going to feast.”

That sounded exactly like Thanksgiving in our family. It also left me with a wide-open assignment. I could bring dessert, pick up something from a restaurant, or volunteer to make a side. Then I remembered the last time I tried to impress my family with homemade macaroni and cheese. With my sister’s in-laws coming, this feels like a good year to let somebody else make it.

How My Family Cooks Thanksgiving Dinner

I’ve been fortunate enough to have my mom cook Thanksgiving dinner every year. She usually preps and bakes the turkey, makes her stuffing and candied yams, and bakes the ham. I have six siblings, and four of us usually pitch in. Between us, we make mashed potatoes, bake the mac and cheese, help prep the ham, peel vegetables, clean the space where we’ll eat, set the table, and decorate. Once I start listing those jobs, I can see how much work goes into the dinner I’ve been lucky enough to sit down to every year.

Every so often, one of us changes a recipe or tries a new one, and it goes over so well that it earns a spot on the table again. My macaroni and cheese went in a different direction. I wanted to make it from scratch, and the recipe called for cheddar. At the time, I had no idea how much the flavor could vary from one cheddar to another. I picked a very sharp one, and that flavor took over the whole dish.

My younger siblings, now 18 and 20, have remembered that meal for years. My attempt earned me a family ban from making Thanksgiving mac and cheese, and I have yet to serve a redemption batch. In my defense, the recipe really did say cheddar. I still think I have an award-winning mac and cheese in me. The judges in my family may need a little more convincing.

What We Put on the Table

When I tried to write down what we serve, I started with turkey and ham and somehow ended up at sparkling apple juice. Lasagna can make an appearance, too. Alongside the main dishes there might be mashed potatoes and gravy, mac and cheese, steamed broccoli, carrots or corn, a mixed salad, rice, and beans. My mom’s stuffing is made with ground beef and vegetables, and we have homemade green and red salsa on the table. We also serve corn tortillas, flour tortillas, and King’s Hawaiian Original Hawaiian Sweet Rolls. By the time I got to the fruit, I was still remembering sides I’d left off.

A spread of strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, and raspberries might sit alongside pumpkin pie, ice cream, and whipped cream. There’s usually something for everyone to drink, from juice pouches and lemonade to soda, sparkling water, and sparkling apple juice. For the adults, there might be Modelo, tequila, or wine. It’s easy to see how my sister could tell me to show up hungry without naming a single thing she planned to make.

Even when my mom is doing the cooking, part of our dinner comes from somewhere else. We’ve shopped at Costco, Sam’s Club, Stater Bros., and Cardenas. If we’re in the mood for a particular dish, we’ll order it for pickup. I’d happily bring Lucille’s biscuits or mac and cheese, a cheesecake from The Cheesecake Factory, or bolillos from the local panadería. Those are things I already know I’d be excited to see on the table, and I can decide how much to bring once I have a better idea of the head count.

What I Found When I Priced Out Dinner

Looking for something to bring to my sister’s made me curious about what it would cost to buy the whole meal. Until now, my family has always done some of the cooking ourselves. I wanted to see what I might spend if I let a grocery store or restaurant handle dinner one year. The prices below are what I saw while shopping a week before Thanksgiving. Holiday menus and availability can change.

Store or restaurant Meal Serves Listed price
Stater Bros. · Fontana Prime rib or turkey holiday dinner 6 $69.99 each
Ham holiday dinner 6 $99.99
Sprouts · Rancho Cucamonga Natural turkey or spiral-sliced ham meal 6 $89.99 each
Organic turkey or grass-fed rib roast meal 6 $129.99 each
Costco · Rancho Cucamonga Beef tenderloin roast meal (8 lb.) 6 $159.99
Turkey dinner (sold out when I checked) 8 $199.99
Sam’s Club · Ontario Carver ham meal with four sides 8 $129.99
Golden Corral · Ontario Whole roasted turkey meal 6–8 $259.99
Bone-in pork roast or beef roast meal 6–8 $169.99 each
Lucille’s · Rancho Cucamonga Thanksgiving family feast 10+ $329.99
Thanksgiving supper Up to 6 $199.99
Holiday BBQ supper Up to 6 $225.99
Whole smoked turkey (ready to heat) Unlisted $99.99
Cardenas · Ontario Ham, turkey, or pork dinner packages Unlisted $89.99–$99.99
Ralphs Thanksgiving feast dinner 8–10 $190
Boar’s Head boneless turkey dinner 4–6 $100
Boneless turkey dinner 4–6 $95

At Stater Bros., the turkey and prime rib dinners worked out to roughly $12 per person for six guests before any extras. The serving counts also helped me narrow the options. If I wanted to cook my own sides, I could buy just the smoked turkey from Lucille’s.

Costco’s turkey dinner was already gone by the time I checked again. Seeing that option disappear was a reminder to look up the ordering deadline while I’m still deciding what I want.

Cardenas listed two pounds of mashed potatoes, a pumpkin pie, 12 dinner rolls, and a pound of gravy in each package. I didn’t see a serving count, so I’d ask before ordering for a crowd.

After looking through the menus, I can picture three ways to handle Thanksgiving when it’s my turn to host. I could cook everything from scratch, make a few favorites and buy the rest like my mom does, or order dinner. If something unexpected eats up my prep time, a package could take care of the main dish, sides, and dessert. I’d start with a head count and figure out what I’d still want to add. Two dinners for six might cost more than one larger feast once I buy extra sides and drinks.

For next week, I still have a day or so to decide what to bring to my sister’s. I’m leaning toward picking something up. If she already has dessert covered, I can get bolillos or see if she could use another side. I want to bring enough to share and give her one less thing to think about while she’s hosting.

What I Want to Make for My Son

My mom told me that when I was a child, I said I didn’t like the way she made the Thanksgiving turkey. Back then, she cut the turkey into pieces so it would cook faster, then served the slices on a big platter. I wanted a whole turkey like the ones families brought to the table in TV shows and movies. After I told her that, she learned to cook a turkey whole. Now that my son is getting older, I can picture him asking me for the exact same thing. If that’s karma, I’d better ask my mom to show me how she does it before he gets the chance.

I want my son to have good memories of Thanksgiving, and I’m curious what he’ll remember most. Maybe it will be that whole turkey. Maybe it’ll be helping me set the table or getting to put whipped cream on his own piece of pumpkin pie. I can start by learning one dish from my mom and figuring out which parts of the meal I enjoy making. Then I can budget for the dishes I’d rather pick up, the same way she’s done over the years.

After Thanksgiving, I’ll have 365 days to put together a menu my son might like, shop around for what fits my budget, and learn how my mom gets that whole turkey on the table. Somewhere in those 365 days, I’ll pick out a milder cheddar and make a practice batch of mac and cheese. If it turns out the way I hope, my younger siblings are getting the first two helpings.

Contact Info

Corporate Office

PO Box 6090, La Quinta CA 92248.

Phone Number

(909)-483-0474

Email Address

[email protected]

Get In Touch